The Hunt I Didn’t Plan by: Garrett Petersen

Published by

on

The Hunt I Didn’t Plan

A last-minute change of plans, a crowded mountain, and a handgun.

 

A plan was finally coming together, I had the angle and position I needed. Dropping onto the rock, I quickly ranged the buck, 386 yards, dialed my scope, and settled in. The buck was still oblivious, feeding deeper into the canyon towards the other deer. 

With my hands shaking and my mind racing, I took a moment to close my eyes and breathe. When I opened them, the buck was there in my scope. This was my opportunity. With the crosshairs settled just behind the shoulder, I pulled the hammer back and squeezed the trigger.

Looking back, it’s hard to believe how differently I had pictured this hunt unfolding. I had spent weeks planning and preparing for what I thought would be the perfect opening morning, but sometimes the best memories come from the moments you never planned for.

Where It All Began

My desire to hunt with handguns came from an unexpected friendship with Mladen Simovic, an accomplished handgun hunter whom I helped pull out of the snow while he was hunting late-season cow elk with his 44 Mag. The idea of harvesting western big game with a handgun stuck with me, and eventually I decided to pursue it myself.

The Plan

Planning for this hunt started long before opening morning. For nearly a year, I had been thinking about hunting mule deer with a handgun. I wanted to go into this hunt with a plan and as few unanswered questions as possible.

After a successful cow elk hunt together, the idea came to hunt alongside Mladen for mule deer in mid-September in western Wyoming. We both had tags and began planning out a backcountry trip for five days in an area where he had harvested a big buck last season.

The Preparation

In the months leading up to the hunt, I put a lot of time and effort into ensuring that both myself and my gear would be up to the task. I tested my gear on multiple trips, honing my camping skills, improving my glassing, and practicing engaging targets at varying distances accurately from a variety of resting positions. I even competed in the Handgun Hunters Competition, where I could really put myself to the test. I learned a lot and managed to tie for fourth, placing fifth, in the single-shot division.

https://handgunhunterscomp.com/

Plan B

Unfortunately, while I was making the drive out for our hunt, Mladen called to say he was hurting pretty badly. Going into the backcountry with an injury is never a good idea, so we decided it was best to call off the hunt. Rather than abandon the idea of a handgun hunt, I shifted gears and began planning a hunt in the general unit south of my home.

My new plan was to hunt solo, hiking into a difficult-to-access section of public land that I knew the deer liked. I knew that if I made it to the spot in time, I could catch the deer as they fed out of the meadows and up into pockets of timber putting myself in position for a shot. I had spent time scouting the area and had a pretty clear picture of how I thought opening morning would unfold.

Another Change of Plans

Opening morning rolled around, and I was up early, excited for the day ahead. With my gear all loaded up, I helped make sure my girlfriend and son were both ready for work and daycare before heading out. I stopped to top off on gas and grab a few last-minute things before hitting the road.

I hadn’t made it far when I received a call from my girlfriend saying there was an issue at daycare and I would need to come get my son so she could head to work. I turned around frustrated, feeling like my plans had fallen apart once again. When I arrived home to a four year old, upset that he wouldn’t be able to go to school, I thought about just staying home. After all, I had no gear ready for him, no plan for where to go since he couldn’t come along to my originally planned hunting areas, and a grumpy toddler isn’t exactly the best hunting partner.

The Hunt Wasn’t Over

I laid down on my bed, still frustrated at what my morning had become. I started thinking about all the effort that had gone into getting ready for this day. I knew I was still capable of making something happen. I would just have to make do. I got up and started gathering my son’s gear, loaded everything into the truck, and we hit the road.

A long hike through dense sagebrush and timber wasn’t going to happen with a four year old. I knew I would have to keep close to the truck. My new plan was to cover and glass as much ground as possible. I had an area in mind that could give us a good opportunity, but timing was going to be important. Opening day of any general deer tag is always hectic, but I knew if I could beat the crowd we had a shot. The area was similar to where I had originally planned to hunt, just a little less rugged, with good road access and plenty of public land. 

Timing is everything

As I got close to the area I planned to hunt, I saw a few vehicles approaching from other directions and the first bit of light creeping over the hills. The delayed start had me running late, and the sky began to wake, bringing life to the hills.

As I approached a gate leading to the short stretch of road before the first spot, I spotted another truck heading that way from a different road. I barely managed to make it into the area ahead of them. With little room for multiple hunters, they continued on somewhere else.

The Hunt Begins

Upon reaching our destination, we got out of the truck and began glassing trying not to waste any time. I could make out a few does feeding in the sage, along with a few smaller bucks. This unit requires a buck to have at least four points on one side, and I was hoping to find something more mature so we moved on.

A short distance later I spotted a good herd of elk with a nice bull. My son was pretty excited and put his hands over his ears, as if he was expecting me to shoot. Unfortunately, elk season was still another two weeks away.

After seeing the elk, we moved on to another area. I parked the truck and walked a short distance to get a better look into a large draw. I immediately spotted a group of deer, I could see with my binoculars there were a few bucks in the group, but I couldn’t tell if they were anything worthwhile. I was turning to grab my spotting scope when movement caught my eye roughly 800 yards away. It was another deer with its head down feeding. When it lifted its head, instantly I knew that it was a mature, legal buck. Meanwhile, my son was still back in the truck, enjoying a Danish and some juice, completely unaware of what I had just spotted.

Game Time

The buck was alone, a few hundred yards to the right of the other group of deer. He wasn’t a giant by any means, but with a quick look, I knew he was a deer I would be happy to take, especially considering how the morning had unfolded.

I rushed back to the truck to grab my gear. My son asked if I’d seen one, and when I said yes, his eyes widened with excitement and he jumped out of his seat, asking to go get him. With my gear in hand and him by my side, we began working our way up a steep hill before reaching a large rocky outcropping. I had to carry him for a short ways over some rocks before we reached easier terrain.

I spotted the buck again about 500 yards away. I reassessed the situation and realized the sage was too tall where he was, and with the shot angle, I wouldn’t be able to get close enough while maintaining a clear shot with my revolver. I would have to use my TC Encore pistol in 7mm-08, which I’d had strapped to the outside of my pack, and approach from another direction.

We slowly began creeping toward the buck to close the distance. We reached a dead tree where I ranged the buck at 340 yards. He was still oblivious, feeding slightly away from us. I put earplugs on my son and sat him down while I set up my shooting bag and loaded my gun.

When I got into position, the buck had fed slightly downhill, and I no longer had a shot. He was feeding into a large roll in the hillside. Once the buck was out of sight, I gathered my gear, and we continued a little farther until we reached a large rock. We stopped there and waited for the buck to reemerge, but after several minutes, he still hadn’t appeared. I thought I had somehow messed it up, my plan wasn’t working, and I was going to loose this buck.

I had my head down looking at OnX to see where the deer may have disappeared too, when my son whispered, “I think I see one”. With his upside-down binoculars, he had spotted the buck coming out of the roll.

The Moment of Truth

I looked up to see the buck feeding broadside above me on the hill. A plan was finally coming together, I had the angle and position I needed. Dropping onto the rock, I quickly ranged the buck, 386 yards, dialed my scope, and settled in. The buck was still oblivious, feeding deeper into the canyon towards the other deer. 

With my hands shaking and my mind racing, I took a moment to close my eyes and breathe. When I opened them, the buck was there in my scope. This was my opportunity. With the crosshairs settled just behind the shoulder, I pulled the hammer back and squeezed the trigger.

The shot rang out, echoing off the hillsides. I raised my head to see the buck still standing there. My son shouted excitedly, “You got him!” without really knowing if I had. I quickly chambered another round and got back down on the gun. The buck was hunched up, clearly hurt, and just as I went to take another shot he began stepping backwards. I watched as the buck took five steps back before his hind legs dropped and he went head over hoof onto the sage. He was down! I got him, and with my best friend there to witness it all.

As we approached the deer I saw that my shot had hit its mark. A perfect double lung shot accounting for the steep quartering to angle. My son and I sat down beside the deer taking in the situation. After a few pictures and high fives I got to work. Thanks to some steep cattle trails, dragging the deer about 800 yards back to the truck wasn’t as bad as expected. The ride home was pure bliss, a successful hunt, smiles all around, and the relief of knowing all my efforts had paid off.

Beyond the harvest

Reflecting on this hunt, I can’t help but notice that the harvest itself, more than ever, is not what I’m most proud of. The journey leading up to it taught me so much about who I am, what I’m capable of, and what means the most to me. I pushed myself hard and discovered potential I didn’t know I had. I found a new passion in handgun hunting, and above all, I got to share the entire experience with those closest to me. 

 

Leave a Reply

×